Disinheritance by will in Italy
The will, an act of last will, allows planning the destination of one’s patrimony after death. In Italy, inheritance law is regulated by the Codice Civile, which balances testamentary freedom with the protection of forced heirs, to whom the law recognises an inderogable inheritance share, namely the spouse, the children and the ascendants.
Sometimes, testamentary provisions can generate conflicts among heirs, especially when they deviate from the expectations of forced heirs. Disinheritance, a controversial institution but admitted by Italian case law, allows the testator to exclude an heir from the succession. Such clause, although valid for non-forced heirs, cannot harm the rights of forced heirs. In case of harm to the share of forced heirship, the harmed heirs can contest the will to obtain the reduction of testamentary provisions and the restoration of the share due to them.
With consolidated experience in the field of international inheritance law, Boschetti Studio Legale provides qualified advice both for the drafting of disinheritance clauses compliant with the law, and for the protection of inheritance rights of those who have been excluded from the inheritance. Our team of professionals is committed to ensuring the full validity of testamentary provisions and to assisting forced heirs in obtaining the share of forced heirship due to them according to the regulation in force.
- Testamento
- Testamento olografo
- Legato testamentario
- Impugnazione testamenti
- Impugnazione testamento per lesione di legittima
- Come trovare un testamento
- Redazione del testamento
- Testamento internazionale
- Diseredazione per testamento
- Azione di restituzione del testamento
- Reintegrazione della quota di legittima
Disinheritance clause
Disinheritance is a testamentary clause through which the testator expressly excludes a subject from their succession, whether legitimate or testamentary. Although not expressly provided for by the Codice Civile, Italian case law has admitted its insertion in a will, provided that it does not compromise the rights of forced heirs. Indeed, it is appropriate to specify that, should a forced heir be disinherited, they can contest the will and, with the successful exercise of the action of reduction, obtain the recognition of their reserved share.
In the past, it was held that the will could contain only patrimonial provisions, attributing assets with economic value. Disinheritance, not providing for a direct attribution, was considered inadmissible. However, notarial practice has circumvented this obstacle through “indirect disinheritance”, attributing the entire patrimony to other subjects.
Subsequent case law evolution has recognised that disinheritance produces indirect dispositive effects, modifying the distribution of the patrimony among the other heirs. The Corte di Cassazione has clarified that disinheritance, although having a negative content, can imply an institutive will towards the non-excluded heirs. Sentence n. 8352 of 2012 confirmed the validity of disinheritance even when it constitutes the sole content of the will, recognising it as a dispositive deed that regulates succession relationships.
Sentence n. 26062 of 17/10/2018 clarifies that the disinheritance clause has personal effect and does not extend automatically to the entire bloodline of the excluded subject. Sentence n. 8352 of 25/05/2012, instead, confirms the validity of the disinheritance clause as an instrument to regulate post mortem patrimonial relationships. Disinheritance, although having a negative content, can imply an indirect dispositive will in favour of the non-excluded heirs.
A particularly debated aspect concerns the relationship between disinheritance and legitimate succession. According to the prevailing orientation, disinheritance prevents the excluded subject from succeeding not only by will, but also by law. This interpretation is based on the principle whereby testamentary will prevails over legitimate succession, which operates only in the absence of testamentary provisions or for the part not disposed of.
The disinheritance clause must be explicit and unequivocal, clearly manifesting the testator’s will to exclude a particular subject. But, as we have seen before, it can also be implicit, if deducible from other testamentary provisions suitable to exclude certain heirs from the succession.
Boschetti Studio Legale, expert in international inheritance law, offers specialised assistance to those who wish to insert a disinheritance clause in their will, ensuring its validity and respect for the regulation in force. We also assist those who have been unjustly disinherited, protecting their rights and helping them to obtain the share of forced heirship due.
Contact us for personalised advice and for an assessment of your specific case.
Can forced heirs be disinherited?
A frequent question in succession matters concerns the possibility of providing for the disinheritance of forced heirs, that is to say of those subjects (spouse, children and ascendants) to whom Italian law reserves an inderogable share of the inheritance patrimony. In particular, one wonders whether the disinheritance of the child is admitted.
The answer to this question, although having been the subject of debate in doctrine and case law, is negative. Disinheriting a relative is possible, but disinheritance cannot harm the rights reserved by law to forced heirs.
In Italian inheritance law, the protection of the share of forced heirship represents a fundamental principle, aimed at ensuring minimum protection to forced heirs. Although the testator can freely dispose of only the available share, it is not excluded that a testamentary clause may attempt to compress or exclude the rights of forced heirs, as in the case of a disinheritance clause.
This is because such provisions would not definitively prejudice the rights of forced heirs, since the law nevertheless provides that they can exercise the action of reduction to assert their right to the reserved share and obtain the restoration of the succession proportions imposed by law.
However, the case law of the Corte di Cassazione has repeatedly confirmed the invalidity of disinheritance of forced heirs, underlining the need to ensure the reserved share provided for by law. Among the most recent merits pronouncements, sentence n. 1335/2021 of the Tribunale di Pavia can be cited, which reaffirms this principle, stating that a disinheritance clause directed at a forced heir is inadmissible.
If the testator attempts to disinherit a forced heir, the latter has the right to act in reduction to obtain the reintegration of their share. The action of reduction allows contesting the will and restoring the correct division of the inheritance patrimony, ensuring the forced heir the share due to them by law.
Boschetti Studio Legale, expert in international inheritance law, offers specialised assistance to those who wish to plan their succession in compliance with the rights of forced heirs, and need a lawyer to obtain guarantees on the validity of the will and not to incur the risk of future inheritance disputes.
We also assist those who consider themselves harmed in their rights as forced heirs, providing advice and legal support for the action of reduction. Contact us for personalised advice and to protect your interests in succession matters.
Difference between disinheritance and unworthiness
Unworthiness to succeed is configured as a civil sanction that excludes an heir from the succession for having committed serious and unlawful behaviours, listed exhaustively in article 463 of the codice civile. These behaviours, often of a criminal nature, qualify the individual as not deserving to benefit from the inheritance patrimony.
Unlike testamentary disinheritance, where it is the testator who voluntarily excludes a subject, unworthiness is a measure established by law. The unworthy person can be called to the inheritance, but cannot retain it; this requires a judicial declaration that formalises the exclusion.
Among the behaviours considered unworthy fall acts such as the homicide or attempted homicide of the de cuius or of their family members, serious slander, falsification of the will or wilful impediment to the testamentary will of the deceased. These acts are divided into two main categories: those that compromise the physical or moral integrity of the deceased and those aimed at manipulating the distribution of the patrimony.
For unworthiness to produce effects, a judicial proceeding initiated by the subjects who could benefit from the succession in substitution of the unworthy person is necessary. The constitutive sentence has retroactive effect, obliging the unworthy person to return any inheritance assets and fruits received. Acts of ordinary administration carried out by the unworthy person before the pronouncement remain valid, while those of extraordinary administration may lose effectiveness if gratuitous, or be validated if the third-party contractor acted in good faith.
A particular case concerns parents declared unworthy. The law provides that these cannot exercise usufruct and administration on the assets inherited by their children, to avoid an indirect advantage. In such situations, a curator is appointed to manage the patrimony.
Scenari tipici / Casi studio
Gli scenari tipici sono stati elaborati da una fusione delle fattispecie più significative di diritto di famiglia che lo Studio tratta abitualmente, al fine di creare un caso strutturato e complesso, utile al lettore per orientarsi nella gestione del proprio caso personale. I casi studio illustrano invece vicende singole, realmente trattate, con dati e dettagli anonimizzati per garantire la riservatezza dei clienti.
Registrazione del contratto di convivenza e regolarizzazione del partner straniero
Coppia residente a Roma: cittadino italiano e compagna straniera priva di documenti di soggiorno. Ricorso cautelare ex art. 700 c.p.c. per tutela della convivenza, seguito da pratica per carta di soggiorno familiare UE.
Adozione di maggiorenne per riconoscere un rapporto familiare di fatto
Cittadino statunitense residente a Roma con legame affettivo stabile con lo zio acquisito. Procedimento per adozione di persona maggiorenne ex artt. 291 e ss. del Codice Civile per formalizzare il rapporto familiare.
Contratto di convivenza per coppia italo-brasiliana: tutela patrimonio e permesso di soggiorno
Imprenditore italiano e compagna brasiliana conviventi da tre anni a Milano. Tre vulnerabilità interconnesse: migratoria, patrimoniale e successoria, risolte con un intervento coordinato su tre fronti paralleli.
Adozione in Colombia: coppia italiana realizza il sogno dopo 3 anni di percorso
Una coppia sposata da otto anni intraprende l’adozione internazionale con la Colombia. Un percorso attraverso due ordinamenti, tre istituzioni italiane e l’autorità centrale colombiana.
Successione con eredi in 4 paesi diversi: coordinamento Italia-USA-UK-Svizzera
Un imprenditore italiano lascia un patrimonio distribuito tra Italia, Stati Uniti e Svizzera, con quattro eredi in altrettanti paesi. Quattro ordinamenti, quattro sistemi fiscali da coordinare in parallelo.
Adozione maggiorenne figlio del partner: riconoscimento legame affettivo ventennale
Un uomo di cinquantotto anni chiede di adottare il figlio trentenne della moglie, cresciuto insieme da vent’anni. Un legame reale che la legge non riconosceva, con implicazioni successorie per i figli biologici.
Impugnazione testamento per lesione di legittima: recuperati 800.000 euro per gli eredi
Due figli ricevono 20.000 euro ciascuno da un testamento che lascia quasi tutto alla seconda moglie del padre. Un’azione di riduzione per lesione della quota di legittima risolta in mediazione.
Pianificazione successoria azienda familiare: passaggio generazionale da 3 milioni
Un imprenditore di sessantadue anni deve trasferire un’azienda da 50 dipendenti al figlio che la gestisce, tutelando la figlia che ha scelto un altro percorso. Patto di famiglia e holding per garantire continuità.
Adozione internazionale da parte di single: quando la legge apre una strada che pochi conoscono
Una donna single di quarantacinque anni intraprende l’adozione internazionale. Un percorso giuridicamente possibile ma poco conosciuto, che richiede una strategia legale specifica fin dal decreto di idoneità.
Eredità digitale: gestione criptovalute e asset digitali del defunto
Un professionista muore lasciando criptovalute per oltre 600.000 euro su wallet e exchange, senza istruzioni di accesso. Un patrimonio digitale che rischiava di andare perduto per sempre.
Rettifica del nome per persona transgender: documenti coerenti con la propria identità
Una professionista trentaduenne, in trattamento ormonale da otto anni, con documenti ancora al nome maschile di nascita. La discrepanza anagrafica generava outing forzati quotidiani in ambito lavorativo, bancario e amministrativo.
Attribuzione di sesso e aggiornamento di oltre 20 documenti: dalla sentenza alla nuova identità anagrafica
Un dirigente di 45 anni con sentenza di rettificazione già ottenuta si trova davanti al vero ostacolo: coordinare carta d’identità, patente, laurea, contratti di lavoro, mutuo e polizze assicurative presso enti con procedure non uniformate.
Legal advice for disinheritance in the will of the child or of a relative
Disinheritance, as we have seen, is a complex act that requires careful assessment, especially in an international context. The complex family dynamics and differences between legal systems can make the disinheritance of a child or a relative in favour of foreigners a delicate process rich in nuances.
In these cases, it is fundamental to turn to a professional experienced in international inheritance law. Boschetti Studio Legale offers specialised assistance in matters of disinheritance also in international contexts, with particular attention to:
- Verification of the validity of the disinheritance: we assess the legitimacy of the disinheritance clause in light of the law applicable to the specific case, considering the nationality of the testator, of the heirs and the situation of the assets.
- Protection of the rights of forced heirs: in case of disinheritance of a child or a forced heir relative, we analyse Italian and international regulation to ensure respect for the share of forced heirship.
- Drafting of an international will: we assist in the drafting of a will valid in all the Countries involved, in full respect of the wishes of the testator and of the applicable regulations.
- Resolution of inheritance disputes: we offer advice and legal support for the resolution of disputes linked to disinheritance, both extrajudicially and judicially.
If you wish to disinherit a child or a relative in favour of a foreigner, or if you consider yourself unjustly excluded from a will, contact Boschetti Studio Legale for personalised advice. Our team of experts will guide you through the complex legal procedures, protecting your interests and ensuring the correct application of the law.
Relying on a law firm for international inheritance law is the best choice to ensure the validity of the will and prevent future inheritance disputes.
Hai questioni legate alla famiglia o alle eredità? Siamo qui per aiutarti. Lasciaci i tuoi dettagli qui sotto e parliamone. Ti contatteremo nel più breve tmepo possibile per capire come potremmo supportarti al meglio.
Via dei Gracchi, 151
00192 Roma – Italy
info@familylawboschetti.com
Tel: + 39 – 06 889 21971
solo su prenotazione
Giorno: Lunedì – Venerdì
Orari: 9.00-13.00 / 16.00-20.00
How does disinheritance work?
Disinheritance is an act through which a person, by means of the will, decides to exclude a subject from their inheritance. To be valid, disinheritance can be explicit and unequivocal, clearly indicating who is excluded and for what reason, or it can result implicitly, as a consequence of the testamentary provisions.
How to exclude a child from the inheritance?
Excluding a child from the inheritance, being a forced heir (as in the case of children, spouse and parents), is not possible in Italy. The law protects these subjects with a minimum share of the inheritance called "share of forced heirship". It is possible to exclude a child only from the available share of the patrimony, but not from their share of forced heirship.
How to be disinherited?
There is no way to "be disinherited". The decision to disinherit someone belongs solely to the person who makes the will.
How to exclude a legitimate heir from the will?
Excluding a legitimate heir, that is to say a subject called to the inheritance in the absence of a will, is possible by drafting a will in which one disposes of one's patrimony in favour of other subjects. Therefore, the testator can freely decide to exclude legitimate heirs from the succession, except in case of forced heirs to be protected with the reserved share.
When can a child be excluded from the will?
A child can be excluded from the will only as regards the share of patrimony exceeding their share of forced heirship. The share of forced heirship is a minimum share of the inheritance that the law reserves to children, spouse and parents and cannot be affected.
